What To Know
- The G20, on the other hand, adopts a sleeker, more modern design with a detachable handle and a smaller LCD screen that can be rotated and flipped.
- Both the Canon Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20 offer excellent image quality, but the G20 takes the lead in several areas.
- Both the Canon Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20 feature built-in stereo microphones, but the G20 offers a more robust audio recording experience.
Choosing the right camcorder can be a daunting task, especially when faced with a plethora of options. Two popular contenders in the Canon lineup are the Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20. While both offer impressive features, there are key differences that might make one a better fit for your specific needs. This comprehensive comparison will delve into the intricacies of each camcorder, helping you make an informed decision.
Design and Build Quality
Both the Canon Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20 boast compact and ergonomic designs, making them comfortable to hold and operate. The R46 features a more traditional camcorder aesthetic with a familiar handgrip and a large, rotating LCD screen. The G20, on the other hand, adopts a sleeker, more modern design with a detachable handle and a smaller LCD screen that can be rotated and flipped.
In terms of build quality, both camcorders are well-constructed and feel durable. The R46’s body is primarily made of plastic, while the G20 incorporates a metal chassis, giving it a more premium feel. The G20 also boasts a weather-resistant design, making it more suitable for outdoor shooting in challenging conditions.
Image Quality and Video Recording
Both the Canon Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20 offer excellent image quality, but the G20 takes the lead in several areas. The G20 utilizes a larger 1/2.84-inch CMOS sensor compared to the R46’s 1/3.2-inch CMOS sensor. This larger sensor captures more light, resulting in better low-light performance and a wider dynamic range, allowing for more detail in both highlights and shadows.
The G20 also offers a higher maximum video resolution of 1920 x 1080 at 60p, compared to the R46’s 1920 x 1080 at 30p. This higher frame rate provides smoother playback and better slow-motion capabilities. Furthermore, the G20 features advanced image processing technologies, including Canon’s DIGIC DV 4 processor, which enhances image quality and reduces noise.
Manual Controls and Customization
For serious videographers, the Canon Vixia HF G20 provides superior manual control and customization options. It offers a comprehensive suite of manual settings, including aperture, shutter speed, ISO, and white balance. This allows for more creative control over the image and gives you the flexibility to adjust settings based on specific shooting conditions.
The G20 also includes a professional-grade lens with a 32x optical zoom, offering greater flexibility in framing your shots. The R46, while offering a decent 57x advanced zoom, lacks the same level of manual control and lens quality as the G20.
Audio Recording and Features
Both the Canon Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20 feature built-in stereo microphones, but the G20 offers a more robust audio recording experience. It includes a dedicated XLR audio input, allowing you to connect external microphones for professional-quality audio capture. This feature is particularly useful for filmmakers who require high-fidelity sound for their projects.
The G20 also boasts a wider range of advanced features, including slow-motion recording, time-lapse photography, and a built-in ND filter. These features provide greater creative flexibility and expand the possibilities for capturing unique footage.
Battery Life and Connectivity
The Canon Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20 both offer decent battery life, but the G20 has a slight advantage. Its larger battery capacity allows for longer recording times compared to the R46. However, both camcorders can be powered via a USB connection, providing flexibility for extended recording sessions.
In terms of connectivity, both camcorders offer standard options like HDMI output, USB, and SD card slots. The G20, however, includes a more comprehensive set of ports, including a microphone input, headphone jack, and remote control terminal, making it more versatile for professional workflows.
Choosing the Right Camcorder: A Summary
The choice between the Canon Legria HF R46 and the Vixia HF G20 ultimately depends on your specific needs and budget.
Canon Legria HF R46:
- Best for: Casual videographers, budget-conscious users, and those who prioritize portability.
- Pros: Compact design, affordable price, easy-to-use interface, decent image quality.
- Cons: Limited manual controls, lower video resolution, basic audio recording.
Canon Vixia HF G20:
- Best for: Serious videographers, professionals, and those who require advanced features and manual control.
- Pros: Superior image quality, comprehensive manual controls, professional-grade audio recording, weather-resistant design, advanced features.
- Cons: Higher price, larger and heavier than the R46.
The Final Verdict: A Powerful Choice for Professionals
While the Canon Legria HF R46 offers a solid entry-level camcorder experience, the Vixia HF G20 stands out as a powerhouse for serious videographers and professionals. Its superior image quality, manual control, advanced features, and professional audio recording capabilities make it a compelling choice for those demanding the highest level of performance.
What You Need to Know
Q1: Is the Canon Vixia HF G20 worth the extra cost over the Legria HF R46?
A1: If you’re a serious videographer who values manual control, advanced features, and professional-quality audio recording, then the Vixia HF G20 is definitely worth the extra cost. However, if you’re a casual user who prioritizes portability and affordability, the Legria HF R46 might be a better fit.
Q2: Does the Canon Vixia HF G20 have any limitations?
A2: While the G20 is a powerful camcorder, it does have some limitations. Its battery life, although decent, isn’t as long as some other camcorders. It’s also larger and heavier than the R46, which might be a consideration for users who prioritize portability.
Q3: Are there any other camcorders worth considering in this price range?
A3: Yes, there are other excellent camcorders available in this price range, such as the Sony FDR-AX100 and the Panasonic HC-VX981K. These camcorders offer similar features and performance to the Vixia HF G20, so it’s worth comparing them to find the best fit for your needs.
Q4: Can I connect the Canon Vixia HF G20 to a computer for editing?
A4: Yes, the Vixia HF G20 can be connected to a computer via USB for transferring footage and editing. It also supports various video editing software, making it easy to work with your footage.
Q5: What type of external microphone is compatible with the Canon Vixia HF G20?
A5: The Vixia HF G20 features a dedicated XLR audio input, making it compatible with a wide range of external microphones, including professional-grade models. You can choose from different types of microphones based on your specific recording needs, such as lavalier microphones, shotgun microphones, or stereo microphones.