Canon Legria HF M46 vs Sony Nex Vg20e: The Ultimate Camcorder Comparison

Choosing the right camcorder can be a daunting task, especially when faced with a plethora of options. Two popular contenders often come up in discussions: the Canon Legria HF M46 and the Sony NEX VG20E. Both boast impressive features and capabilities, but which one emerges as the champion? In this comprehensive comparison, we delve into the strengths and weaknesses of each camcorder, helping you make an informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences.

Video Quality: A Tale of Two Sensors

The heart of any camcorder lies in its image sensor, and here, the Canon Legria HF M46 and Sony NEX VG20E take different approaches. The Legria HF M46 employs a 1/3.2-inch CMOS sensor, while the NEX VG20E utilizes a larger APS-C sensor, similar to what you’d find in entry-level DSLRs. This difference in sensor size translates to noticeable variations in video quality.
The larger sensor in the NEX VG20E offers several advantages. It captures more light, resulting in better low-light performance and a wider dynamic range, which allows for more detail in both highlights and shadows. This translates to richer, more vibrant colors and a more cinematic look. The larger sensor also enables a shallower depth of field, allowing you to isolate your subject and create beautiful bokeh effects.
On the other hand, the smaller sensor in the Legria HF M46 compromises slightly in low-light performance and dynamic range. However, it excels in image stabilization, thanks to Canon’s renowned optical image stabilization system. The Legria HF M46 also boasts a powerful zoom lens, reaching up to 57x optical zoom, which is significantly more than the NEX VG20E’s 18x optical zoom.

Audio Capabilities: A Symphony of Sound

For many videographers, audio quality is just as important as video quality. Both the Canon Legria HF M46 and Sony NEX VG20E offer decent audio recording options, but they differ in their capabilities.
The Legria HF M46 features a built-in stereo microphone, which provides decent audio quality for basic recording. However, for more professional results, you’ll likely need to invest in an external microphone. The NEX VG20E, on the other hand, comes equipped with a built-in stereo microphone and a hot shoe that allows you to connect an external microphone, giving you more flexibility and control over your audio recordings.

Design and Ergonomics: A Comfortable Grip

Both camcorders offer a comfortable grip and user-friendly interface. The Legria HF M46 features a compact and lightweight design, making it easy to carry around. Its intuitive controls and menu system make it simple to navigate and adjust settings. The NEX VG20E, while slightly larger and heavier, offers a more professional feel. Its larger grip and dedicated buttons provide a more robust and comfortable shooting experience.

Connectivity and Features: A World of Possibilities

In terms of connectivity, both camcorders offer a range of options. The Legria HF M46 features HDMI output, USB connectivity, and SD card slots for storage. The NEX VG20E provides similar connectivity options, including HDMI output, USB connectivity, and SD card slots, but it also offers a built-in microphone jack and a headphone jack for audio monitoring.
Both camcorders come with a variety of features to enhance your video recording experience. The Legria HF M46 boasts advanced features such as face detection, slow-motion recording, and time-lapse recording. The NEX VG20E offers similar features, including face detection, slow-motion recording, and time-lapse recording, but it also includes additional features like manual controls, zebra patterns, and peaking, which are particularly useful for professional videographers.

Battery Life: A Powerhouse of Endurance

Battery life is a crucial factor to consider when choosing a camcorder. The Legria HF M46 offers a respectable battery life, allowing you to record for a considerable amount of time before needing to recharge. The NEX VG20E, on the other hand, has a shorter battery life, which can be a drawback for extended shooting sessions. However, it’s worth noting that the NEX VG20E uses a standard NP-FV battery, which is readily available and can be purchased in bulk for extended recording needs.

The Verdict: A Matter of Perspective

So, which camcorder comes out on top? The answer depends on your individual needs and priorities.
The Canon Legria HF M46 is an excellent choice for:

• Beginner videographers: Its user-friendly interface and compact design make it ideal for first-time users.
• Travelers: Its lightweight design and powerful zoom lens make it perfect for capturing memories on the go.
• Those who prioritize image stabilization: Canon’s renowned optical image stabilization system ensures smooth and steady footage.

The Sony NEX VG20E is a better option for:

• More experienced videographers: Its manual controls and professional features cater to those seeking more creative control.
• Those who prioritize video quality: Its larger sensor delivers superior low-light performance, dynamic range, and a more cinematic look.
• Those who need flexibility: Its hot shoe allows for external microphone connections, offering greater audio recording options.

Beyond the Comparison: A Look at Alternatives

While the Canon Legria HF M46 and Sony NEX VG20E are excellent camcorders, they may not be the perfect fit for everyone. Consider exploring other options depending on your specific needs:

• For a budget-friendly option: The Canon Legria HF R80 offers a similar feature set to the HF M46 at a lower price point.
• For a more compact and portable option: The Sony RX100 series of cameras provides excellent video quality in a compact form factor.
• For a more professional-grade option: The Sony FS5 or Canon C100 offer advanced features and capabilities for serious videographers.

Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Tool for the Job

Ultimately, the best camcorder for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences. Both the Canon Legria HF M46 and Sony NEX VG20E offer unique strengths and weaknesses, and the choice between them boils down to your priorities.
If you’re a beginner videographer looking for a user-friendly and compact camcorder with excellent image stabilization, the Legria HF M46 is an excellent choice. However, if you’re a more experienced videographer seeking superior video quality, manual controls, and professional features, the NEX VG20E is a better option.
Remember to carefully consider your needs and budget before making a decision.

Answers to Your Questions

Q: What is the difference in resolution between the Canon Legria HF M46 and Sony NEX VG20E?
A: Both camcorders record Full HD video at 1920×1080 resolution.
Q: Can I connect an external microphone to the Canon Legria HF M46?
A: Yes, the Legria HF M46 has a microphone input for connecting an external microphone.
Q: Does the Sony NEX VG20E have built-in image stabilization?
A: No, the NEX VG20E does not have built-in image stabilization. However, you can use a stabilizing rig or external lens with image stabilization.
Q: Are there any other camcorders that I should consider?
A: Yes, there are many other camcorders available on the market. Some popular alternatives include the Canon Legria HF R80, Sony RX100 series, Sony FS5, and Canon C100.
Q: What are the main differences between a camcorder and a DSLR for video recording?
A: Camcorders are specifically designed for video recording, offering features like built-in image stabilization, zoom lenses, and user-friendly controls. DSLRs, on the other hand, are primarily designed for still photography, but they can also record video. DSLRs typically offer more manual controls and interchangeable lenses, giving you more creative flexibility.